For quite some time I’ve edited my images in LR in a specific way, let’s call it a workflow of sorts. It would be the following Global adjustments via the Basic Panel
White Balance
Crop
Spot removal
Decrease Blacks
Open shadows
Add presence - Texture, Clarity and Dehaze
Exposure/Whites and Highlights if necessary
Then would come the Localised adjustments
Vignette preset - mostly set to Medium
Graduated filters
Radial Filters
Rarely the adjustment brush
Then perhaps Lens Corrections (both Chromatic Aberration and Profile Correction) and a bit of HSL if any specific colours needed adjusting.
This workflow has served me well, but of late I find myself pulling away from such a rigid workflow and trying to find a more holistic approach to editing images. Crop and Spot removal are still my first goto adjustments but after that I try to look at the overall image and ask myself what it is that I originally saw when taking the image and what it is that I am trying to show to the viewer, even if the only viewer ends being me.
I look at specific areas and see what it is about those areas that I want to show or hide, enhance or detract the eye from. Not being a painter I don’t know if this is correct but I feel like I’m starting to use the RAW file like a very detailed but flat sketch of the overall image I am trying to produce. My job now that I’ve captured the scene is to add highlight and shadow, enhance and mute colour, add depth and texture, all the time leading the viewer through the scene. If something is unimportant in the scene it is my job to make sure the viewer is not, on first viewing, being drawn anywhere but where I choose to take them, to see what I see, or saw (pre-visualised) when composing the image.
One of the big changes I’ve found is that I am using the Adjustment Brush much more now, but rarely in a defined way. I use it to dab adjustments onto the scene, a little clarity here, a bit of blacks there. Rarely do I use it for large contiguous areas, for that I still use the Radial Filter or for skies etc I use the Graduated Filter. Combining this way of working, using very soft feathered brushes, allows me to avoid the dreaded halos that LR still creates around areas, particularly if you are using big adjustments or Auto-mask.
The above Image is copyright Gabriela Atkinson.